Alright everyone, the mystery has been SOLVED!
I followed Tim's advice and installed a KOSO temp gauge and found out my van is running 175 - 190! Even after installing an OEM temperature sending unit, my gauge is way off. Looks like I'll be relying on the new gauge instead of my stock gauge.
I can also rest assured that I now have an all new cooling system. Looks like I'm ready to head to Key West in April for the first major trip.
Thank you all again for the generous help.
-Hugh